Managing Multigenerational Teams: A Culture Problem

November 16, 2026•7 min read

Managing multigenerational teams often brings the same complaint to the fore, running in both directions. The older colleagues say the younger ones lack patience for process, expect everything immediately, and treat hierarchy as an insult. The younger colleagues say the older ones cling to protocols that serve no purpose, mistake formality for substance, and refuse to adapt. Each side experiences the other as a problem of character, a matter of people being difficult, entitled, or stuck.

This framing almost guarantees that friction will continue because it locates the difficulty in personalities rather than where it actually lies. The more useful way to understand generational tension at work is to recognize that it is not really about age. It is about culture.

Generations Are Cultural

This is not a loose analogy or an act of generosity. Generational patterns meet the working definition of culture quite precisely. They are absorbed during the formative years, when the brain is most plastic, and shaped by shared historical experience. People who come of age during the same events develop remarkably similar templates for what feels normal, respectful, and efficient. Those templates persist into adulthood, quietly shaping how a person reads everything from an email’s tone to the pace at which a decision ought to be made.

Once you see this, the supposed character failings start to look like something else. A colleague who grew up in the postwar decades, when stable hierarchy and clear protocol kept institutions from falling apart again, did not adopt formality out of stubbornness. They learned, early and deeply, that structure is how you keep things safe. Someone who came of age as a latchkey kid amid rapid technological change learned self-sufficiency because the environment demanded it, which is why they may prefer to be told what they need to know and then left alone to handle it. Someone who entered adulthood during the digital revolution, watching what happened when decisions were made behind closed doors, learned to value transparency and collaboration. Each pattern is logical once you know the world that produced it.

Why the Generational Cheat Sheet Is the Wrong Tool

Having accepted that generations are cultural, the temptation is to reach for a reference guide: a tidy summary of what Boomers want, what Gen X needs, and how to talk to Gen Z. This is exactly the wrong move, and it is worth being clear about why. Consider whether you would make a comparable cheat sheet for any other dimension of human difference, such as a one-page guide to communicating with people of a particular ethnicity or gender. The discomfort that suggestion produces is precisely the point. A generational cheat sheet commits the same error; it simply feels more acceptable because birth year seems like objective data.

That apparent objectivity is itself a trap. Because a birth year is verifiable, generational categories can feel more solid than they are, and that false solidity breeds overconfidence in our assumptions. Yet a fifteen- to twenty-year span contains enormous variety. A careful meta-analysis of generational differences in work attitudes found that the actual differences between generations in areas such as job satisfaction and organizational commitment are much smaller than popular accounts assume, and often smaller than the differences among individuals within any single generation (Costanza et al., 2012). Knowing that someone was born in 1985 gives you a hypothesis rather than an answer.

Generation is a starting point. It is never the destination. Your client is more than their birth year, and so is everyone they seek to understand.

The Layers Beneath the Label

A further reason to hold generational categories lightly is that no one is only their generation. The same forces that shape a cohort intersect with race, gender, class, and personal history, producing patterns that a single-lens reading will misinterpret. A communication style that appears to reflect a generational preference for hierarchy may also reflect decades of learning to navigate professional spaces not built to welcome the person, where challenging authority carried real and unequal risks. An efficiency that reads as generational may reflect years spent proving competence in rooms that assumed it was lacking.

Economic circumstances add another layer that the generational label obscures entirely. Two people born in the same year, into the same broad cohort, can carry very different templates if one family moved through that era with security and the other through precarity. The conditions of a person’s formative years are not uniform across a generation; they are filtered through the specific circumstances their family actually lived through. This is why a generational explanation, reached for too quickly, so often misses what is really shaping the person in front of you. The same dynamic underlies the cost some people pay to fit a workplace’s defaults, which I take up in a companion piece on fitting in.

What Managing Multigenerational Teams Actually Requires of Leaders

The default is to treat one generation’s norms, usually those of whoever holds positional power, as simply professional and to expect everyone else to adapt to them. As a result, the labor of adjustment falls unevenly. Younger employees code-switch throughout the day to match a style that does not come naturally, while their older colleagues are quietly permitted to opt out of learning new tools. Both sides of this imbalance are worth naming, because neither is fair and neither serves the work.

Genuine navigation across generations means distributing the labor of adaptation rather than assigning it to one group. It means those whose templates formed before the digital era taking real responsibility for developing those skills, and those who came up inside it working to understand the relational wisdom behind more traditional approaches. It is also worth noticing how much common ground the generational framing obscures. When you look past the friction, the supposed adversaries often want strikingly similar things. Among US employees, for instance, a hybrid arrangement is the preferred way of working in every generation, from a narrow majority of baby boomers to seven in ten Gen Z workers, and fully on-site work is the least popular option across all of them (Pendell & Agrawal, 2025). The divide frequently turns out to be narrower than it feels from inside the conflict.

In consulting with teams across many countries, I have found that the move that actually helps is also the simplest, and it is the same move that navigation calls for across any kind of difference. Rather than guessing what someone needs based on their birth year, ask. What communication styles help you do your best work? How do you prefer to receive feedback? These are not throwaway intake questions. They honor both the pattern and the person, treating the generational template as useful context while leaving room for the particular human being it never fully describes. The leader who does this stops managing a demographic and starts working with an individual, which is where the friction begins to resolve.

This is the argument I develop more fully in my book, Coaching Across Cultures: A Guide to Cultural Navigation (Wiley, 2026): the same practice of curious, ongoing attention that serves us across cultures of origin serves us equally across the cultures that different eras quietly build into us. The generation in front of you is real, but it is never the whole story.


If you are navigating generational dynamics on your team

If you are exploring this for a team, event, or organization, book a Your Next Steps Chat, a free 30-minute conversation to explore whether a keynote, workshop, or consulting engagement is the right fit.

You can also learn more about speaking engagements and consulting work.

Coaching Across Cultures: A Guide to Cultural Navigation is available now from Wiley. Also at Amazon and other booksellers.

References

Costanza, D. P., Badger, J. M., Fraser, R. L., Severt, J. B., & Gade, P. A. (2012). Generational differences in work-related attitudes: A meta-analysis. Journal of Business and Psychology, 27(4), 375–394.

Pendell, R., & Agrawal, S. (2025, July 22). Fully remote work least popular with Gen Z. Gallup. https://www.gallup.com/workplace/692675/fully-remote-work-least-popular-gen-z.aspx


Dr. Jonathan Marion

Dr. Jonathan Marion

Dr. Jonathan Marion is a transformational life coach, ICF PCC, Mentor Coach, and Professional Fellow of the Institute of Coaching at McLean Hospital (a Harvard Medical School affiliate). Formerly an award-winning anthropology professor and author, and a past president of both the Society for Visual Anthropology and the Society for Humanistic Anthropology.

Back to Blog

© Steps Along The Way